Find the newest homes for sale & real estate listings in Shelley! In this competitive market it’s important to stay on top of the newest listings & to alert us on anything you would like to see. If you would like more information on any of these Shelley homes for sale, just request information on the listing details page of the property. We can provide you with information that’s not available to the public including disclosures, past sales history, dates and prices of homes recently sold nearby, and more.
And, if you haven’t already, be sure to register for our website so that you can receive email alerts whenever new Shelley homes for sale come on the market.
Updated October 27, 2026
Single-family, condominium and manufactured-with-land sales as reported by the Snake River Regional Multiple Listing Service.
Bingham County market (includes Shelley and Blackfoot). Last 3 months (July 27, 2026 – October 27, 2026): 91 homes sold, median sold price $353,000, median 38 days on market, median sold-to-list price 98.42%. Last 6 months (April 27, 2026 – October 27, 2026): 231 homes sold, median sold price $375,000, median 30 days on market, median sold-to-list price 99.21%. On October 27, 2026 there were 156 active and 49 pending listings, about 5.1 months of supply at the 3-month sales pace (4.1 at the 6-month pace). Medians are the middle value. County-wide figures, not Shelley-only.
Based on information from the Snake River Regional Multiple Listing Service for the period April 27, 2026 through October 27, 2026 (3-month: July 27, 2026 through October 27, 2026). Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. General market information, not an appraisal. Search East Idaho homes for sale
Shelley is in Bingham County, just south of Idaho Falls, and it's home to Idaho Spud Day every September. It's an easy drive to both Idaho Falls and Blackfoot. Here's a quick local rundown.
From the center of Shelley, Idaho Falls is about 15 minutes away (about 9 miles) and Blackfoot is about 25 minutes (about 20 miles). Drive times are rough estimates for normal conditions; winter weather can add time. If you'll be commuting, try the drive at the time of day you'd actually make it before you commit to a home.
Shelley is in Shelley Joint School District 60. The state's Idaho Report Card lists Shelley Senior High School and Donald J Hobbs Middle School, with the elementary grades split across Dean Goodsell, Sunrise, Riverview and Hazel Stuart elementary schools. Confirm the district for a specific address, since district lines don't always follow city limits. You can look up enrollment, programs and contact details for any Idaho public school on the Idaho Report Card, from the Idaho Department of Education.
Idaho Spud Day is held on the third Saturday of September every year. The City of Shelley lists a Senior Citizens Pancake Breakfast, a parade, a Spud Picking Contest and a Spud Tug among the annual events.
Idaho Falls is about 15 minutes north, so the River Walk, the Idaho Falls Zoo and the city's events are part of everyday life here too.
Blackfoot, about 25 minutes south, has the Idaho Potato Museum and the Eastern Idaho State Fair.
For a feel of the market, start with the Bingham County snapshot above. It covers the whole county, including Blackfoot, so it isn't a Shelley-only number. Let us know what you're hoping to find, and we'll pull recent sales right around Shelley to compare. Whatever you buy, a few questions are worth asking early: how old the roof, furnace and water heater are, whether the home is on city water and sewer or a private well and septic system, and how the street or driveway is cleared in winter. We'll help you get those answers before you write an offer.
Thinking about buying or selling in Shelley? We'd love to help, whether you're just starting to look or you're ready to go. Call or text Ali and Josh at 208-271-4250. There's no pressure, just honest answers.
Keller Williams Realty
All Rights Reserved
Client Reviews
“Ali was THE BEST to work with! I found her because of her ratings and they spoke the truth!! She was efficient, easy to communicate with, friendly, and very helpful through the whole process of selling a home! I would recommend her to anyone! She helped us sell so quickly and smoothly!! The entire process was efficient!!”
“Ali and Josh were great to work with! Josh was the one who listed our home. He was very helpful and attentive throughout the whole process, which made it so easy as we moved out of state during our sale. He also had great connections to help us with repairs. Definitely recommend!”
“Ali was great during the whole buying process! She helped tremendously with our lender. She was very responsive to numerous calls, and was always able to answer any questions we had. Will definitely be using for future purchases! Thanks Ali!”
Reviews shown word for word from Google. Rating and count as of Oct 21, 2026.
